#60MinutesWithCP: After SARS 'Reform’, What Next?
After months of pressure on social media from Nigerians for the Special Anti-Robbery Squad (SARS) of the Nigeria Police Force (NPF) to be scrapped with the hashtag (#EndSARS), the federal government eventually succumbed and ordered an 'overhaul'.
For months, Nigerians cried out over series of misconduct carried out by officers of the unit ranging from harassment, extortion and assault to extra-judicial killings.
Then on August 14, 2018, the then Acting President, Yemi Osinbajo, directed the Inspector-General of Police, Ibrahim Idris, to "overhaul the management and activities" of the notorious Police unit.
While many Nigerians applauded the supposed end of the unit, many expressed confusion with what the 'overhaul' meant exactly.
Later on, the Force's Public Relations Officer, Jimoh Moshood, released a statement where he detailed the steps the Force has taken to heed Osinbajo's 'overhaul' directive.
Here's a list of the new changes announced by the Police:
1. The unit will now be known as Federal Special Anti-Robbery Squad (FSARS). "All SARS teams nationwide have been collapsed under FSARS," read the statement.
2. A new Commissioner of Police has been appointed as the overall head of FSARS nationwide. The Commissioner of Police (FSARS) is answerable to the Inspector General of Police through the Deputy Inspector General of Police, Department of Operations.
3. The FSARS, previously under the Force Criminal Intelligence and Investigations Department (FCIID), is henceforth to operate under the Department of Operations, Force Headquarters Abuja.
4. As directed by Osinbajo, the FSARS will be intelligence-driven and will be restricted to the prevention and detection of armed robbery, kidnapping and the apprehension of offenders linked to the stated offences only.
5. New FSARS Commanders will be appointed across the country and operate in the State and Zonal Commands under the Commissioner of Police (F-SARS) at the Force Headquarters, Abuja. A Federal SARS Commander of a Rank of Chief Superintendent of Police (CSP) but not below Superintendent of Police (SP) will be in charge of FSARS in State and Zonal Commands across the Country.
6. There will be Human Rights Desk Officers for FSARS in every State to take complaints from the public and forward same to Force Headquarters, the officer will be answerable to the Commissioner of Police (FSARS) at the Force Headquarters and not Commander FSARS in the States.
7. Medical/psychological evaluation of all FSARS personnel will be carried out immediately.
8. Redesigning of new uniform with identity name tags for all FSARS personnel throughout the country will be done immediately.
9. FSARS personnel will not perform Stop and Search duties except on distress call to respond to armed robbery and kidnapping offences only.
New Wine In Old Bottle
This is, however, not the first time a government establishment would be overhauled or re-organised, the challenge has always been when this happens, there is little or no improvement after.
Government establishments such as the National Electric Power Authority (NEPA) and the Nigerian Telecommunications Limited (NITEL) have all gone through some form of overhauling or re-organisation as it were but with little or no positive effect.
NEPA, for instance, metamorphosed to PHCN and now to private power distribution companies but the service seems to have remained largely the same. NIPOST also did not really fair better after they were re-branded.
This is the more reason some Nigerians are skeptical about Osinbajo's 'overhaul' directive and subsequent statement released by the Police.
The Inspector-General of Police, Ibrahim Idris, on Monday, September 10th told operatives of the reformed Federal Special Anti-Robbery Squad to desist from checking citizens’ bank account details.
The IG also warned the F-SARS operatives not to invade people’s phones and laptops unless there was a court order or an instruction from the Commissioner of Police in charge of a state police command.
Idris warned that any F-SARS operative who violated the new rules would be dismissed from the force.
But a critical look at the measures put in place by the IGP shows that even though it offers the public, communication channels for reporting grievances against FSARS, it does not commit the police force to ensuring that every complaint made against FSARS operatives will be promptly and fairly investigated, and where substantiated, result in a definite outcome.
It is important to note in this context, that the police force has always had communication lines for reporting unlawful or unprofessional behaviour of its officers.
The problem is that, oftentimes, complaints, after they are made, draw a blank and those complained against do not get questioned or punished at the end of the day.
Sometimes too, complainants are transposed into crime suspects to punish them for daring to complain. The proposition, therefore, to re-use this old template this time around without more, as a response to the presidential directive, is clearly a no-brainer.
Idris’ new review measures failed to offer concrete proposals for ensuring that safeguards against abuse are effective.
One thing is as certain as daybreak, if the police force remains the way it is, the overhaul of the SARS Unit will be largely unfruitful and unsustainable over time.
Please be informed that the Lagos Commissioner of Police - Edgar Imohimi will be hosted LIVE at Bounce office on Thursday, September 13. Follow the media chat on all our social media platforms.
WATCH: 60 Minutes With Lagos State's Police Boss